Saved changes and restarted apache and then later the entire server...
Tested by browsing to the AirTime page which worked just fine. Now rather than self-signed warning, cert looked good with no flags in Chrome.
However, now when going to the Monit page and the IceCast server pages, they will pause and then automatically forward to https which was not setup for those apps and then throws an ERR_CONNECTION_CLOSED.
iptables -L -n
Shows nothing setup
As a workaround, I installed the certificate for Monit and then enabled a secure port within IceCast so I can at least access the webpage.