[livesupport-dev] LS first impressions
  • Hi,

    I managed to compile CVS source and install LS on gentoo system manually
    - so I can test some functionality now.
    My first impressions:

    1) Scheduler and htmlUI are out of sync - htmlUI shows that scheduled
    list is already playing but audio signal really really comes around 30
    secs or more afterwards
    2) When scheduling for example at 19:20 list snap next to hour 19:00 -
    htmlUI shows its playing but really there is no audio
    3) When htmlUI shows that the playlist is finished the audio signal is
    also killed but song is not finished yet as it is lagging behind
    4) htmlUI doesn't refresh play meter anymore after song changes - have
    to refresh manually to get up-to-date status
    5) I have fades in playlist but no fades between songs really happen
    6) When having Add Audio or Media library pages - scratchpad audio clip
    javascript info overlay is going crazy
    7) gLiveSupport aka Studio OnAir application allows to login and some
    screens do have some functionality but as I can see most of
    implementation is still missing and therefor it's not usable in real
    life for now
    Cool LiveSupport supports currently only simple timed playlists - no timed
    events macros or other macros, no timed next events, no carts, no
    possibility to step forward manually in playlist currently playing, no
    current playlist modifying, no current playlist mix editing - so nothing
    to do with it right now on usual FM station as only very basic
    functionality exists but thats not enough for proffessional FM station.
    Is there a development roadmap and are there thoughts about this kind of
    features?
    9) No playlist composer aka music selector functionality - ok there are
    commercial alternatives, so that is not the highest priority.

    You guys have done a great job so far and as a result of that an good
    base framework for further development exists - but there is a huge
    amount of development to do still before it gets really usable in real
    life. Advanced playlist events and components such as carts and timed
    events, macros are essential for FM broadcasting. In that matter Salem
    Radios Rivendell is way ahead as it has most of things - functional and
    mostly stable studio playout, media library management, etc , but no
    music selector and no web frontend. LiveSupport on other hand seems to
    be well designed overall but implementation still needs a lot of work as
    of now. If I can be helpful with designing some needed features for LS
    or with testing LS - I gladly would do that.

    I'll post the bugs into bugtracking systems later when I've played with
    it a bit more.

    Cheers,
    --

    Andres Toomsalu, andres@active.ee
    juhataja - general manager, O